Browse All Oyster Bay NY Historical Properties for Sale

Welcome to 64 Tooker Avenue, a beautifully restored 1893 colonial offering approximately 2000 ft.; of character filled living space in the heart of Oyster Bay. Thoughtfully improved and meticulously maintained, this 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home blends original craftsmanship with comfortable modern living. Inside, refinished hardwood floors, painstakingly restored original millwork, period details and custom built-ins reflect the home’s history, while a sun filled southern exposure creates bright, inviting spaces throughout. The first floor offers a formal dining room, living room, renovated kitchen, sunroom, mud/laundry room and a handsome home office with custom doors, cabinetry and bookshelves. Upstairs 3 bedrooms and a finished attic provide flexible space for work, play, guests, or additional storage. An exceptionally clean and bright, lower level provides abundant storage, pantry space, and a dedicated room for a workshop or hobbies. The home’s outdoor spaces have been transformed into a private retreat. Thoughtfully designed landscaping surrounds a fenced yard with a Trex deck, Cambridge paver patio, bluestone walkways, perennial gardens and raised vegetable beds, all supported by a 10 zone irrigation system. A detached garage and freshly painted exterior complete the property. Set on approximately 0.186 acres in Oyster Bay-East Norwich School District, 64 Tooker Avenue offers the rare combination of historic character, thoughtfully updated living spaces and beautifully designed outdoor areas all meticulously cared for and ready for its next chapter. Ideally located just blocks from Oyster Bay Hamlet’s restaurants, shops, and museums, with the LIRR, local beaches and waterfront parks all nearby.

64 Tooker Avenue, Oyster Bay

$1,149,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1026156 MLS

Welcome to 43 Kellogg Street, a Wonderful Blend of Historic Charm and Contemporary Living Located in the Heart of Oyster Bay. At First Glance, the Home's Victorian-inspired Architecture and Inviting Wraparound Porch set a Gracious Tone. Inside Gleaming Hardwood Floors Introduce a Warm and Welcoming Interior Featuring a Spacious Living Room with an Archway to the Beautiful Formal Dining Room that Seamlessly Blends into the Newly Renovated Open-Concept Kitchen with Quartz Countertops, a Striking Marble Backsplash, Pantry and Stainless Steel Appliances. The Counter Seating Enjoys an Open View into the Expansive Sun-filled Great Room and Adjacent is a Delightful Three-Season Room Offering the Perfect Place to Relax or Read. A New Powder Room and Additional Access to the Beautifully Landscaped Private Yard with a Stone Wall and Steps to Vibrant Seasonal Flowers, Lush Perennial Bushes and Specimen Plantings plus a Charming Stone Pathway Further Enhance the Peaceful Backyard Sanctuary. The Second Level Features a Spacious and Light Filled Primary Suite with WIC and Vaulted Ceiling Overlooking the Backyard Oasis Along with Three Additional Bedrooms and a Full Bath. A Generous Sized Three Room Attic with Vaulted Ceiling, Enhanced by Abundant Natural Light and Lovely Views, Provides Wonderful Additional Space and Versatility. This Special Home is Ideally Located just a Short Distance from Oyster Bay's Vibrant Downtown Where you can enjoy Charming Shops, Cafes, and Acclaimed Restaurants that Give this Historic Hamlet it's Distinctive Character. Nearby, Theodore Roosevelt Memorial Park offers a Sandy Beach, Marina, Ballfields, Tennis, Pickleball Courts and Most of all Breathtaking Sunsets. The Oyster Bay LIRR Station is Conveniently Located Nearby. 43 Kellogg Street Offers an Inviting Combination of Character, Modern Updates, Beautiful Outdoor Space, and an Exceptional Oyster Bay Lifestyle.

43 Kellogg Street, Oyster Bay

$365,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1030473 MLS

Welcome to Lexington Estates located in the Heart Of Beautiful Oyster Bay, a vibrant waterfront town! Bright, Spacious, Welcoming apartment with open floor plan boasts gleaming hardwood floors, oversized windows, professionally designed modern kitchen and remodeled full bathroom with walk-in shower. Convenient To downtown Oyster Bay, where one can find a variety of Restaurants with Alfresco Dining, Shopping, Library, Parks, Beaches, Boating, Fishing, Long Island Railroad and schools. Laundry and storage on premises in the basement. Maintenance is $953.36/mo. and includes Taxes, Heat, Water, Gas, Garbage Removal, Grounds Maintenance and Parking.

200 Lexington Unit #1F, Oyster Bay

$899,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1030222 MLS

Beautifully renovated and filled with natural light, this exceptional Victorian is set on a picturesque property in the heart of Oyster Bay. Thoughtfully updated while preserving its original character, the home showcases updated kitchen and baths, freshly painted rooms, timeless architectural details and incredible backyard gardens. The main level offers an ideal layout for today's lifestyle, featuring a spacious chef's eat-in kitchen with pantry, a full bath, formal living and dining rooms, a welcoming family room, and a private office or gym perfect for working from home. Upstairs, the expansive primary suite serves as a peaceful retreat with a beautifully updated en-suite bath. Two additional bedrooms and another renovated full bath complete the second floor. A finished third-floor bonus space provides endless possibilities as a playroom, studio, guest area, or additional office. Also has EV Charger. Combining historic elegance with modern updates, this move-in ready home offers the perfect blend of character, comfort, and convenience just moments from Oyster Bay's vibrant downtown, restaurants, shops, parks, beaches, and the LIRR.

51 Tooker Avenue, Oyster Bay

$4,998,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1026267 MLS

Immerse yourself in this stunning waterfront villa on Centre Island. Although newly rebuilt inside and out, the original character of this 1929 colonial creates an amazing synergy between modernity and history. Perched comfortably above the bay, the backyard slopes gracefully towards the water's edge with a new seawall. The professional landscape plan not only created beautiful grounds, but a number of entertaining and play areas, including a dining terrace with built-in barbeque/prep station. On the eastern side of the home, you are met by a sizeable driveway and a separate two car garage. Upon entering the front door, a beautiful onyx kitchen welcomes you. The charming dining room anchored by its fireplace, French doors face west, allowing you to take in the spectacular views. The cozy living room and its complementary fireplace. Through large French doors is an inviting covered terrace, making it the perfect place to entertain guests, or for intimate moments looking at sunsets over the bay. In addition to the stairs, all floors are accessible via a new elevator. The grand master bedroom comes complete with two large fully outfitted closets and a spa quality bathroom with unparalleled water views from shower and tub. A private balcony off the master offers the perfect place to enjoy a sunset or morning coffee. There are two additional bedrooms, a marble bath, and a small office on the second floor. The perfect weekend getaway or main residence this Centre Island home offers a turnkey option for any waterfront buyer could want. Truly A One-Of-A-Kind! Call For Details.

353 Centre Island Road, Oyster Bay

$1,298,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1018691 MLS

Welcome to this classic Center Hall Colonial, perfectly situated in the heart of Oyster Bay. A charming front porch sets the stage for this timeless home, offering an inviting place to relax and enjoy the neighborhood. Inside a spacious and thoughtfully designed layout features generously sized rooms, creating an effortless flow for both everyday living and entertaining. Sun-filled living spaces combine traditional charm with comfortable functionality, formal living and dining rooms boast lovely, detailed millwork- making this home ideal for today's lifestyle. Step outside to a beautifully landscaped rear property, complete with a deck and hot tub overlooking lush specimen plantings - your own private retreat for outdoor dining, gatherings, or quiet moments surrounded by nature. Ideally located just minutes from Oyster Bay's beautiful beaches, vibrant shopping, acclaimed restaurants, parks and convenient transportation, this exceptional home offers the perfect blend of a classic layout, elegance, comfort and convenience.

6 W Oak Hill, Oyster Bay

$1,350,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1017289 MLS

Welcome to one of the original homes built in Florence Park. It is an unusual community with a Neighborhood Association for its 88 homes. Dues are collected annually and are $30 per household. It covers a beach cleanup, a block party, and a holiday party. The Association has a private bay beach and small boat launching area. The home was built in 1920 and has the charm of the era. Enter through the front covered porch, which is a wonderful place to enjoy quiet summer days and to watch the fire flies light up the night. The Foyer opens into a bright Living Room with wood burning fireplace and century old sliding doors leading to the detailed Dining Room. Directly off the Dining Room is a large screened-in Porch where hours can be spent relaxing. There is a first class eat-in kitchen with marble counter tops and stainless steel appliances with gas cooking. The second floor encompasses the primary Bedroom with walk in closet and Bath, 2 well sized Bedrooms, a full Bath and Laundry. The third floor is spacious and paneled and provides an additional Bedroom and Bath. It is cooled by two window units. The basement is unfinished. The basement door gives access to the outdoor shower, deck and the yard. The basement shelving will remain. There is a second laundry in the basement. The yard provides room for flowers, vegetables and play space. The oversized two car garage with pull down stairs leads to a loft for storage. The garage has had many uses through the years. There is much to enjoy at the house and in the neighborhood. Swimming, kayaking, paddle boarding and sailing from the private neighborhood bay beach only minutes away. The Town of Oyster Bay provides many beaches on the Sound side on the North Shore and the Ocean on the South Shore. The property is convenient to schools, stores, beaches, tennis courts, pickleball courts, Long Island Rail Road, restaurants and the library.

107 Sidney Street, Oyster Bay

$375,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1013323 MLS

Welcome to Lexington Estates in the heart of Oyster Bay! This bright & spacious corner one bedroom co-op offers an abundance of natural light, a desirable open layout, and the added privacy of a corner location. Featuring hardwood floors, oversized windows, a generously sized living room and dining area, and a well-appointed kitchen, this home provides comfortable everyday living. Nestled within a beautifully maintained garden-style community with landscaped grounds, residents enjoy on-site laundry, storage, & ample parking. Conveniently located just moments from Oyster Bay Village, restaurants, shops, parks, beaches, marinas & the LIRR, offering an ideal blend of North Shore charm & commuter convenience.

200 Lexington Avenue Unit #8B, Oyster Bay

$304,999

1 Baths ⋅ 1014455 MLS

Beautifully landscaped and well maintained co-op apartment complex with walkways, patios and sitting areas with on-site superintendent. Second floor studio with high ceilings, 1 AC, open layout, and kitchen with stainless steel appliances. Basement common level offers storage and laundry facilities including bicycle storage room. Conveniently located in the heart of Oyster Bay which is in close proximity to beaches & parks, tennis courts, baseball fields, restaurants, shops, schools, recreational clubs and the Long Island Railroad. Maintenance fee includes taxes, heat, water, garbage removal, landscaping, snow removal, and parking.

200 Lexington Ave Unit #12E, Oyster Bay

$949,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1009941 MLS

All Information Deemed Accurate But Should Be Independently Verified. **Nestled in a desirable Oyster Bay location, this beautifully updated split-level residence offers the perfect blend of timeless elegance and modern comfort.** Boasting 4 generously sized bedrooms and 2 tastefully renovated baths, the home features a thoughtfully designed layout with spacious, light-filled interiors ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The well-appointed kitchen flows seamlessly into inviting living and dining spaces, creating an effortless atmosphere for gatherings. Beautiful hardwood floors throughout the main level. A partial basement with a versatile bonus room provides exceptional flexibility, perfect for a private home office, fitness studio, media room, or guest retreat. Outside, the fully fenced property offers a private backyard oasis with ample space for relaxation and outdoor entertaining. ***The oversized deck has been removed to create a larger yard***. Additional amenities include an attached garage and meticulous upkeep throughout. Ideally situated near Oyster Bay's charming waterfront, boutiques, restaurants, parks, and transportation, this exceptional home presents a rare opportunity to enjoy refined North Shore living in one of Long Island's most sought-after communities.

15 Wood Drive, Oyster Bay

$749,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1006593 MLS

Price Reduction!!! Welcome to this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath colonial style home in the heart of desirable Oyster Bay! Boasting hardwood floors throughout, the entry foyer leads to a spacious living room, a formal dining room, and a kitchen with a pantry area. The finished basement features bilco doors for easy access and added convenience. Step out to a porch, and a tremendous yard, perfect for entertaining! With plenty of driveway parking leading to a two car garage, you're just moments away from downtown Historic Oyster Bay and all it has to offer -- beaches, parks, restaurants, and shops. Bring your TLC and make this home yours!

81 Summers Street, Oyster Bay

$1,325,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 996701 MLS

Existing 3800 sq ft, second floor can be added for an additional 2800 sq ft. Total useable sq ft (with extension) can be above 6400 sq ft. Great Opportunity for extension: Total 2 acre land, you can extend and build your dream house as you like.

19 Tiffany Road, Oyster Bay

$595,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 980900 MLS

Welcome to 46 Irving Place, a charming Colonial tucked away at the end of a quiet street in the heart of Oyster Bay. Perfectly situated just minutes from the train, waterfront, dining, and local restaurants, this home offers both convenience and character. Warm and inviting layout, where classic details blend seamlessly with everyday comfort. Two Bedrooms (possible 3) and 1.5 baths. Its prime location makes it ideal for those who want to enjoy all that this vibrant town has to offer—whether it’s an easy commute, a stroll to the harbor, or nights out at nearby eateries. A true Oyster Bay gem with the perfect balance of privacy and accessibility.

46 Irving Place, Oyster Bay

$1,200,000

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 978908 MLS

Location, location, location! This charming house is in beautiful Oyster Bay with private beach. Beautiful scenery, more than just a home, it's a way of life.

424 Centre Island Road, Oyster Bay

$1,150,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 907283 MLS

Great Investment Opportunity! Currently being used as a Medical Practice, but it can be converted to Family Residence. The property sits on a 12,001 SF Corner Lot with a beautiful curb appeal. The building consists of 4524 SF. Total of 13 rooms. The 1st Floor features 3 Exam Rooms, 2 Doctor's Offices, Reception Area, Waiting Room, 2 Half Baths, Additional Lounge Room for Staff w/ Kitchen, Dining Area, and Full Bath. Basement is partially finished and has lots of Extra Storage Space. Walk-Out-Basement. New Roof. The building has an accessory 1-Bedroom apartment on the 2nd Floor. Large Driveway newly paved, parking space available for 11 cars. Zoning is permitted for Medical Practices Related. Zoning can be changed though a Special Use Permit application with the Oyster Bay Zoning Board of Appeals office, but only for professional services. Prime Location with high visibility and easy access to parkways. Near the LIRR, shops, schools, parks, beaches, restaurant and entertainment.

188 W Main Street, Oyster Bay

$999,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 898143 MLS

Fully Renovated & Move-In Ready Split-Level Home! Welcome to this beautifully updated split-level residence that perfectly blends modern comfort with timeless charm. Featuring 4 spacious bedrooms and 2.5 well-appointed bathrooms, this home is thoughtfully designed to suit today’s lifestyle.Step into a sun-filled, open-concept layout showcasing a stylish living room, formal dining area, cozy family room, and a modern eat-in kitchen with sleek finishes—ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. Elegant hardwood floors, recessed lighting, and tasteful upgrades throughout add warmth and sophistication.The fully finished basement offers versatile space for a home office, playroom, or media lounge, providing flexibility to meet your needs. Outside, enjoy a lush, private backyard perfect for relaxing, gardening, or hosting gatherings.Additional conveniences include a private driveway and ample street parking. Located near top-rated schools, parks, shopping, and major amenities, this move-in-ready gem offers the perfect combination of space, style, and location.Don’t miss the opportunity to make this exceptional home yours!

16 Huckleberry Lane, Oyster Bay

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

Oyster Bay Historical Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Oyster Bay and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!