Browse All Muttontown NY Historical Properties for Sale

Set on two flat, quiet and bucolic acres surrounded by beautiful park-like plantings, mature specimen trees and colorful perennials, this renovated four-bedroom Center Hall Colonial offers serene country setting with exceptional convenience for commuting. A dramatic and elegant entry hall welcomes you with marble flooring and a striking staircase with decorative wrought-iron banister. Just off the foyer is a beautifully appointed full bath featuring custom, high-end porcelain and marble finishes. At the heart of the home is the sleek and stunning eat-in kitchen, thoughtfully designed with two sinks, two dishwashers and a quartzite waterfall center island with seating. GE Café appliances, a French oven and porcelain farmhouse sink complete the sophisticated space. Recessed ceiling lighting and motion-activated floor lighting provide both ambiance and effortless nighttime navigation. Radiant heat adds an additional level of comfort. The spacious formal living room features a wood-burning fireplace with marble surround and an abundance of natural light fro a wall of windows and French doors opening to the bluestone rear patio-ideal for seamless indoor-outdoor entertaining. The sunny formal living room showcases beautiful new wood floors and flows into a private office/den with French doors opening to a covered concrete patio. Upstairs are four bright bedrooms, including a spacious primary en-suite. All bathrooms have been custom designed with luxurious European finishes, including Grohe fixtures, heated towel bars and radiant heat. Outside, the spectacular, level property creates a truly dreamy setting. Expansive lawns, established perrenials and magnificent mature specimen trees surround a fenced, heated Gunite in-ground pool, offering exceptional privacy and a resort-like atmosphere. Numerous recent improvements include new Pella windows throughout, an updated cesspool, roof and plumbing, a new boiler and a full-house generator. Smart-home features allow heating, cooling, washer and dryer functions to be conveniently controlled from your phone. A beautifully renovated home combining timeless elegance, modern amenities and magnificent grounds in an exceptionally peaceful setting. Radiant heat where there's marble tile floors; bathrooms and kitchen and entry hall.

897 Ripley Lane, Muttontown

$1,900,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1031054 MLS

Set on two beautifully maintained, level acres in the heart of Muttontown, a short distance from Muttontown Preserve, which encompasses 550 acres of fields, woodlands, and ponds, this charming 1948 expanded Cape offers timeless appeal, exceptional privacy, and the rare opportunity to choose between the Jericho or Syosset School Districts. Surrounded by mature specimen trees and lush landscaping, the property enjoys a remarkably private setting with no neighboring homes in view. Expansive lawns and colorful perennial gardens further enhance the serene country setting, just minutes from shopping, dining, major parkways, and the LIRR. The welcoming interior features a gracious formal living room with a wood-burning fireplace, a formal dining room with a custom built-in cabinetry, and a sun-filled eat-in kitchen that opens to a cozy den. French doors lead to a spacious paver patio, creating an effortless transition to outdoor living and entertaining. The first-floor primary suite offers comfort and convenience with an en-suite bath, while the second level features three additional bedrooms and a full bath. A powder room completes the main level. Outside, the fenced in-ground Gunite pool is surrounded by beautiful landscaping and expansive level grounds, offering endless possibilities for recreation, entertaining, future expansion, or simply enjoying the peaceful surroundings. An outdoor storage shed provides additional space for gardening equipment and seasonal storage. Additional highlights include and automatic generator, in-ground propane tank, central air conditioning, lawn sprinkler system, attic fan, security alarm, updated boiler, and newer washer and dryer. A rare offering combining classic architecture, beautifully landscaped acreage, outstanding amenities, and an exceptional locations of one of Long Island's most sought-after communities.

1936 Midlane, Muttontown

$1,330,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1035521 MLS

LUXURY RANCH ESTATE - Muttontown, New York This exceptional ranch-style estate represents a rare opportunity in Muttontown s luxury real estate market. Set on 2.8 acres of pristine land, this 3,461 square foot residence offers an ideal balance of elegant design, spacious comfort, and exclusive privacy. The property stands out with its expansive grounds, resort-style inground pool, and versatile living spaces suitable for both intimate family gatherings and grand entertaining. he estate's 2.8 acres provide unparalleled privacy and space in one of Long Island's most prestigious communities. The manicured grounds feature: - **Resort-Style Inground Pool:** Perfect for summer entertaining and family enjoyment - **Expansive Lawn Areas:** Ideal for outdoor activities and events - **Professional Landscaping:** Mature trees, decorative plantings, and seasonal blooms - **Circular Driveway:** Accommodating multiple vehicles with elegant arrival experience - **Outdoor Living Areas:** Multiple patios and seating areas for outdoor enjoyment ALL CASH OR HARD MONEY ONLY. OCCUPIED, SOLD-AS IS / WHERE IS with NO ACCESS TO PROPERTY, DO NOT DISTURB OCCUPANTS. It is a criminal offense to trespass on this property. Buyer agrees to take the property AS-IS including indemnifying the seller related to any occupancy related title exceptions. This property has been placed in an upcoming event. All bids should be submitted at Xome auction website void where prohibited. Please submit any pre-auction offer received through the property details page on Xome auction website.

8 Woodstock Court, Muttontown

$2,495,000

6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1028493 MLS

Welcome to Lion Crest, an established community in one of Muttontown's most desirable locations within the highly acclaimed Jericho School District. Set on a private half-acre surrounded by mature landscaping, this expanded ranch offers the perfect balance of generous living space, comfort, and everyday elegance. Designed with both functionality and flexibility in mind, the home features six bedrooms, four full bathrooms, and a powder room. The main level offers five bedrooms, three full baths and one half bath, ideal for guests or multigenerational living. Upstairs, spacious oversized bedroom suite with an updated full bath and walk in closet to accommodate every lifestyle. The fully finished basement provides exceptional space for recreation, fitness, hobbies, or storage. Outdoors, a beautifully landscaped backyard creates a peaceful retreat, complete with a heated Gunite in-ground pool and patio—perfect for relaxing, entertaining, and enjoying the privacy of the setting. Additional highlights include natural gas heating and cooking, central air conditioning, complete new roof 2024, all hardscape in patio completed 2022, freshly painted exterior 2026 and thoughtfully maintained interiors throughout. Combining a sought-after Muttontown location, the prestigious Jericho School District, and a versatile floor plan, this is a home designed for comfortable living and memorable gatherings. Community Tennis Court, Community Pickleball Court.

70 Karol Place, Muttontown

$1,888,000

6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1018052 MLS

Welcome to this exceptional 6-bedroom Colonial set on a magnificent 2.46-acre flat property in Jericho School district. Offering a versatile floor plan, this residence features two additional rooms on first floor that can easily serve as bedrooms, private home offices, a library or guest quarters. The heart of the home is a stunning European-style eat-in kitchen appointed with top of the line appliances, granite countertops, and abundant space for gathering. The kitchen flows seamlessly into a grand dining room with a fireplace and an expansive family room highlighted by vaulted ceilings, a striking stone fireplace and walls of windows that showcase breathtaking views of picturesque grounds. This impressive entertaining space is ideal for hosting family and friends while enjoying the beauty of the surrounding landscape. The spacious primary suite offers a peaceful retreat with a beautifully updated oversized bath featuring a soaking jacuzzi tub, separate shower, and elegant finishes. Generously sized secondary bedrooms provide comfort and flexibility for today's lifestyle, while abundant closet space throughout the home provides exceptional storage and organization. Step outside to your own country club backyard surrounded by mature specimen plantings. The sprawling grounds feature an inground pool, expansive patio, estate fencing, and endless opportunities for outdoor entertaining, recreation or relaxation. Additional amenities include central air conditioning, whole house fan, lower taxes, and a prime location close to shopping, houses of worship, and major highways for easy commuting. This is a rare opportunity to customize and make this remarkable property your own while enjoying space, privacy, abundant storage, and endless potential in one of Long Island's most desirable communities.

2108 Edge Road, Muttontown

$2,895,000

6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1019700 MLS

- Low Taxes - $36,000 total - Locust Valley Schools - Village of Muttontown, located on the north side of Northern Boulevard/25A, bordering Upper Brookville -4,850 Sq Ft Colonial - 2 Acres - All Upstairs Bathrooms Fully Renovated with high end finishes - Kitchen features Carrara Marble with new Wolf and Sub-Zero Appliances - Bluestone Patio with fully equipped outdoor kitchen featuring DCS Gas Grill, Lynx Pizza Oven, Lynx Refrigerator, Lynx Ice Maker, Lynx Warming Drawer, Gas Fireplace & Outdoor TV - Heated Saltwater Gunite Pool -Approximately 4.5 miles to LIRR Syosset Set on two beautifully landscaped private acres bordering Upper Brookville, 855 Orchard Lane offers a rare combination of refined interiors, exceptional outdoor living and true move-in-ready luxury. This beautifully renovated five/six-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bath Colonial has been thoughtfully updated for sophisticated everyday living and effortless entertaining. The kitchen pairs Carrara marble with Wolf and Sub-Zero appliances, while gracious living spaces feature custom millwork, rich natural materials and a gas fireplace accented in Imperial Danby marble. The primary suite provides a serene retreat with a spa-inspired Calacatta Gold marble bath and Waterworks fixtures. Each additional bath has been individually renovated with designer stone, fixtures and finishes, creating a consistent level of quality throughout the home. Outside is where 855 Orchard Lane truly distinguishes itself. A sprawling Bluestone terrace extends the living space into a private resort-like setting, with retractable awnings, a fully equipped outdoor kitchen featuring a DCS grill, Lynx pizza oven, refrigerator, ice maker and warming drawer, plus a separate outdoor living area centered around a gas fireplace and television. Beyond the terrace, a heated saltwater Gunite pool with waterfall is surrounded by beautiful lawns and mature landscaping, creating an exceptional backdrop for summer afternoons, intimate dinners and large-scale entertaining. With five/six bedrooms, approximately 4,850 square feet (including finished lower level), two-car attached garage and full-house generator, the property delivers substantial amenities without the scale or maintenance demands of an oversized estate. Located in the Village of Muttontown on the north side of Northern Boulevard/25A and bordering Upper Brookville, 855 Orchard Lane offers privacy, acreage and a beautifully finished North Shore lifestyle—all ready to enjoy.

855 Orchard Lane, Muttontown

$3,739,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1016504 MLS

Welcome to an extraordinary Shingle Style Colonial set on 2.37 pristine, bucolic acres in the Incorporated Village of Muttontown. A stately approach begins at a gated entry set back from the road, where stone piers, ironwork and low landscape lighting create a sense of arrival. Beyond the gate a long driveway stretches forward in a clean deliberate line framed on both sides by a formal allee of mature trees. This 4-bedroom, 3-bath residence has been impeccably reimagined for modern luxury living. A full-scale remodel in 2022 was followed by a seamless 1400-square-foot extension and extensive outdoor enhancements completed between 2023 and 2026, resulting in a home that feels both timeless and entirely turnkey. Every detail has been thoughtfully curated with an elevated eye for design, craftsmanship, and comfort. The custom eat-in chef's kitchen is a true showpiece, appointed with paneled Thermador appliances, a professional-grade range and ovens, Miele steam oven and coffee maker, brass fixtures, quartz countertops, and exquisite designer finishes. Designed for both intimate everyday living and gracious entertaining, the spectacular great room features 9-foot ceilings with coffered detail, a gas fireplace and French doors to the patio and rear grounds. Just off the kitchen, the sun-filled living rooms offer an additional gas fireplace and a warm, elegant atmosphere, creating a beautiful flow throughout the main level. Completing the first floor is a bedroom or private office, full bath and mudroom with direct access to the magnificent backyard retreat. Upstairs, the primary ensuite is a serene and sophisticated sanctuary, featuring vaulted ceilings, refined marble and brass finishes, an oversized cast stone soaking tub, and a luxurious dual thermostatic shower. Adjoining the primary suite is a stunning gym or bonus room with cathedral ceilings and abundant natural light, offering the perfect space for wellness, work, or relaxation. Two additional bedrooms share a beautifully appointed full bath, and each bedroom features custom closets, complemented by a linen closet for added storage. A convenient laundry room is located off the primary suite. The grounds are equally impressive, offering a private, resort-like setting with estate-quality landscaping surrounding the residence and cottage, while beautifully framing the patios, walkways, and outdoor living spaces. A 37-zone digital irrigation system keeps the property lush and pristine, enhancing the natural beauty of the acreage throughout the seasons. Thoughtfully designed with both elegance and efficiency in mind, the home features abundant natural light, wide-plank white oak floors, hydronic heating, central vacuum, alarm system, exterior Ring cameras, Sonos sound system, generator and numerous energy-efficient upgrades throughout. A rare and remarkable offering in one of Muttontown's most beautiful settings, this exceptional turnkey residence blends classic Shingle Style architecture with sophisticated modern luxury, exquisite finishes, thoughtful design, and extraordinary detail - all with low taxes $25,492 and located within the Jericho School District.

1920 Midlane, Muttontown

$2,398,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1014197 MLS

Nestled at the end of a private cul-de-sac in prestigious Muttontown, New York, this magnificent four-bedroom, four-bathroom Colonial sits proudly on two lush, beautifully manicured acres within the Syosset School District. A long, scenic driveway framed by tall Green Giant hedging leads to a breathtaking grand foyer, custom archways, and exquisite ceiling details. The main floor features a dramatic, double-sided natural stone fireplace connecting the formal living room and cozy den, alongside a premium chef's kitchen equipped with a custom copper hood, gas cooktop, and warm radiant heated flooring. For maximum efficiency, a highly functional mudroom entrance offers an abundance of storage to match the deep closets throughout the layout. The upstairs layout is reserved for private relaxation, highlighting a dedicated second-floor laundry room and a luxurious primary bedroom suite boasting expansive walk-in closets and a custom steam shower with radiant heat. The expansive, fully finished basement features a dedicated home gym while still leaving massive additional space for recreation, a media area, or leisure, complete with a code-compliant egress window. The resort-style backyard is an entertainer's dream, featuring a heated in-ground pool with a propane heater, sprawling grounds with ample room for a tennis court, and a spectacular covered backyard portico. Premium infrastructure includes a whole-house Cummins generator, 4-zone climate control, an electric car charging port, buried utility lines, and a newer roof (less than two years old) that covers specifically the primary bedroom section and the backyard portico.

55 Wynn Court, Muttontown

$6,800,000

9 Beds ⋅ 10 Baths ⋅ 1012407 MLS

This mini Oheka castle was a wedding gift given by Otto Kahn for his son. Built in 1936 by Famed Architect John Russell Pope, this French Styled Chateau offers old world details and exceptional millwork throughout. Polished wood plank floors, exposed beams, fine paneling and moldings are some of the original details. The 10.4+ acres is beautiful property featuring an equestrian jump course, paddock, barn with 8 stalls, inground pool, a US Open-grade tennis court, two bluestone patios, flower garden and Award-winning Landscaping. Must see to appreciate all the amenities on this estate. Total acreage can be divided as represented- 1.10.46 Total acres with 1936 house, pool, tennis court and 3 lots $6.8M 2. 2.275 Acre approved Lot on Muttontown East Woods Road $1.7M 3. 2.08 Acre lot with Barn off Midlane Rd $1.6M 4. 2+ Acre approved lot to be developed off Midlane Rd $1.7M 5. 4 Acre Lot at 491 Muttontown East Woods Rd with House, Pool and Tennis $3,995,000

491 Muttontown Road, Muttontown

$3,995,000

6 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ 1010916 MLS

Classic elegance and timeless sophistication define this stately Colonial estate set on approximately 2.73 private acres in the prestigious Village of Muttontown. Offering 6 bedrooms, 6 full bathrooms, and 2 half bathrooms, this exceptional residence showcases a grand center hall foyer, gracious formal entertaining rooms, a spacious chef's kitchen with expansive breakfast area, multiple family and gathering spaces, a private home office, and a luxurious primary suite designed as a private sanctuary complete with dual walk-in closets and a spa-inspired bath. Rich architectural details, generous proportions, and abundant natural light create an atmosphere of refined comfort throughout. Surrounded by beautifully landscaped, park-like grounds, the estate offers a true resort-style lifestyle complete with a heated gunite pool, a three-stall barn, access to preserved nature trails, and serene wooded vistas. Additional highlights include a substantial bonus room, a sprawling lower level offering exceptional recreation and storage space, and a three-car garage. Combining extraordinary privacy, scale, and elegance with the convenience of nearby shopping, dining, transportation, and the highly acclaimed Jericho School District, this remarkable property represents Gold Coast living at its finest.

1862 Muttontown Road, Muttontown

$3,995,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1004527 MLS

Steeped in architectural pedigree and timeless elegance, this extraordinary Muttontown estate, on 3.84 bucolic acres, was designed by renowned architect Marion Sims Wyeth, celebrated for his iconic work on Mar-a-Lago in Palm Beach. Privately tucked behind an impeccably landscaped half mile-long drive off Route 106, the property unfolds as a secluded North Shore sanctuary of exceptional beauty and distinction. Set amidst sweeping lawns, manicured gardens, and picturesque equestrian grounds, the stately brick residence, crowned with a slate roof and introduced by a charming courtyard entry, exudes enduring sophistication. Inside, grand formal entertaining rooms showcase exquisite millwork, original hardwood floors, dramatic wrought-iron railings, and an abundance of French doors that flood the interiors with natural light while seamlessly connecting the home to its breathtaking surroundings. Offering five bedrooms and five-and-a-half baths, the home masterfully balances grandeur with comfort. The formal living room, complete with a fireplace and built-in wet bar, creates an inviting setting for entertaining, while the sunlit breakfast turret and updated chef’s kitchen, appointed with premium professional-grade appliances, provide effortless everyday functionality. A spacious family room and elegant powder room complete the main living spaces. The first-floor primary suite serves as a luxurious private retreat, featuring dual full baths, a fireplace, expansive walk-in closets, and an intimate sitting room. The upper level offers two generously proportioned bedrooms and a beautifully appointed full bath with a thoughtfully separated vanity and shower area. Completing the space is an expansive unfinished attic, presenting exceptional potential for storage or future customization. Additional highlights include a walk-out finished lower level with laundry, bedroom with full bathroom and direct access to the attached two-car garage. Designed for both gracious living and sophisticated entertaining, the residence boasts expansive slate terraces spanning the length of the home, overlooking the stone courtyard driveway, private gardens, charming pergola, and in-ground gunite pool - evoking the romance and refinement of a storybook North Shore estate. A true horse property, the fully fenced equestrian amenities are equally exceptional, featuring a pristine multi-stall barn built-by Morton, thoughtfully designed grazing paddocks, and scenic walking trails woven throughout the grounds. A truly rare offering, this remarkable estate presents an unparalleled opportunity to own a significant piece of Long Island history, all within the esteemed Syosset Central School District.

1780 Route 106 Unit #C, Muttontown

$2,399,000

6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 979551 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully transformed Carriage House, where historic charm meets modern living! This impressive main residence offers a spacious open floorplan, featuring three generous bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms. The heart of the home is illuminated by a stunning wall of windows, flooding the space with natural light and providing gorgeous views of your serene graveled French garden—perfect for entertaining friends or enjoying quiet moments in nature. But that’s not all! Just steps away, you’ll find a Guest House fully renovated and ready for your creative touch. This charming second dwelling is an excellent option for a cozy studio, or an in-law suite. It includes a full kitchen, a sunny sunroom, a handy laundry room, and a half bath on the main floor. Head up the stylish spiral staircase to discover three additional bedrooms and a full bath, offering even more versatile living space. Set on over 2 level acres, this property is a rare find that beautifully combines historic elegance with contemporary comforts, providing you the perfect canvas to create your dream lifestyle. Whether you’re seeking a multi-generational living arrangement or simply a uniquely charming estate to call home, this property invites you to write the next chapter in its wonderful story. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to own this exceptional home that seamlessly blends history and modernity. Tours 24/7

22 Brookville Road, Muttontown

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

Muttontown Historical Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Muttontown and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!